Sickies Garage Brings Big Burger Energy to Bismarck

The ratings picture

Sickies Garage Burgers & Brews holds a 4.5 Google rating from more than 3,200 reviews, a substantial response that points to broad, sustained appeal. Public listings place it in the moderate price tier and span several familiar categories: American restaurant, sports bar, burger restaurant, brewpub and family restaurant. That combination sets expectations accurately. This is a casual, high-energy place built around burgers, drinks and a playful automotive theme rather than quiet dining or polished formality.

The available review sample is largely positive, particularly when diners discuss staff attitude, portion size and the range of choices. One account describes a manager checking on the table in a way that felt friendly rather than rehearsed. Another reports that the team remained pleasant through a busy brunch rush. Those comments help explain why Sickies appears to work for families, groups and diners looking for an easygoing meal.

Burgers lead a broad menu

Burgers are the clearest draw. Reviewers emphasize the size of the selection, with one diner asking a server to choose among three options and ordering the result with tots. The same review names a Jalapeño Peanut Butter Burger with pepper jack cheese and peppered bacon, illustrating how far the menu can move beyond a standard cheeseburger. Another review references a very spicy burger, though the diner was uncertain of its exact name.

The breadth can be a benefit for groups whose tastes vary, but it may also make ordering take longer. Diners who do not want an oversized or highly embellished burger may need to scan carefully for something restrained.

The sample also suggests that Sickies is not limited to burgers and wings. One diner found the steak flavorful with a good texture. A brunch-focused review praised fluffy pancakes, crisp bacon, a well-made iced latte and notably large portions. Since those breakfast observations come from a single account, they are better treated as an encouraging data point than a consistent pattern.

Atmosphere and service

The automotive decor makes a strong impression. One highly playful review compares the room to a NASCAR pit crew environment and describes vehicle-inspired seating. Even allowing for the comic exaggeration, the theme appears to be a major part of the experience rather than a few decorative signs on the wall.

That lively setup comes with predictable noise. A brunch diner noted that the room became louder as business picked up. Anyone hoping to linger over a quiet conversation may find peak periods less comfortable, while sports fans and larger groups may see the same energy as a plus.

Service receives some of the most convincing praise in the sample. Reviewers describe staff as friendly, humorous and visibly engaged. The mention of a manager making a casual table visit adds to the impression of an operation that pays attention to hospitality even when the dining room is busy.

What to expect

Sickies Garage looks strongest as a crowd-pleasing burger and sports-bar stop with character. Portions may run large, the burger list is extensive and the room can become noisy. Dessert feedback is less consistent: one reviewer enjoyed the flavor of a made-to-order ice cream cookie dessert but found the cookie hard and the shake somewhat thin.

Taken together, the large review count, 4.5 rating and recurring service praise make Sickies a solid Bismarck option for casual dining. Its best fit is a diner who values choice, themed surroundings and an upbeat room more than subtlety or calm.