Rusty’s Saloon & Grill pairs steaks with easygoing service

What the public feedback says

Rusty’s Saloon & Grill holds a 4.6 Google rating from 448 reviews, a strong result for a casual bar and grill in Saint Anthony. The available public feedback repeatedly favors the atmosphere and service. Diners describe staff as friendly, quick and attentive, including during busy periods with large parties in the dining room.

The setting also earns notice. One reviewer appreciated that the music stayed at a level that allowed conversation, while another highlighted the choice of indoor and outdoor seating. Taken together, those comments suggest a comfortable local stop for an unhurried meal, drinks or dinner after work rather than a loud, nightlife-first bar.

Food and drink highlights

Cheese curds receive the most emphatic appetizer praise in the sample, with one diner calling them the best they had found in the area. Onion rings and crispy fries also come out well, giving the kitchen a solid showing on familiar fried sides.

Among the larger plates, the ribeye drew praise for tenderness and traveled well as a takeout order. The brisket sandwich also received an enthusiastic recommendation. These dishes fit Rusty’s identity: straightforward bar-and-grill food, filling portions and recognizable favorites rather than an elaborate menu pitch.

Drinks appear to be handled with similar care. A margarita was singled out for being mixed properly, and the bar itself made a strong impression on another visitor. Combined with the conversational music level, Rusty’s looks suitable for groups that want drinks without sacrificing the ability to talk over dinner.

Where expectations need managing

Prime rib is the clearest point of disagreement. One reviewer ordered the smoked prime rib medium rare and found it dry, underseasoned and short on smoky flavor. That diner also felt the queen and king portions appeared the same size and relied on au jus, salt and pepper to improve the meat. The same review still praised the appetizers, server and atmosphere, so the complaint was focused largely on that entrée rather than the overall visit.

That mixed report makes the ribeye or brisket sandwich look like the safer meat choices based on this review sample. It also shows that Rusty’s strongest consensus is around service, atmosphere and casual favorites, not necessarily every steakhouse-style special.

Editorial take

Rusty’s Saloon & Grill appears best approached as a budget-friendly, easygoing gathering place with dependable hospitality. Public reviews support starting with cheese curds, then choosing the ribeye or brisket sandwich with fries, onion rings or both. A margarita rounds out the most consistently positive picture.

The restaurant should appeal to local groups, travelers passing through the area and workers seeking a relaxed meal after a shift. Fast service, takeout that held up well and seating inside or outdoors broaden its usefulness. The prime rib feedback introduces some caution, but the overall pattern remains notably favorable.