Prime + Proper Brings Polished Steakhouse Dining to Nashville

What the public feedback says

Prime + Proper carries a 4.9 Google rating from 576 reviews, and the supplied feedback is notably consistent. Diners repeatedly praise the quality of the beef, polished hospitality and upscale atmosphere. Several frame the restaurant as a new local favorite or one of their best steakhouse experiences in Nashville.

This is firmly an expensive restaurant, so expectations are naturally high. Based on the available reviews, Prime + Proper generally meets them through careful cooking, knowledgeable recommendations and service that feels personal without losing its professionalism. The tone of the feedback suggests a destination built for milestone dinners, client meals and special nights rather than casual steak cravings.

Steaks lead the menu

The filet receives the clearest recurring praise. Reviewers describe it as tender, well cut and cooked with precision. Broader comments about the steaks are similarly enthusiastic, with particular emphasis on meat quality. Wagyu and cowboy ribeye also appear in positive reports, while lamb chops broaden the appeal for guests looking beyond beef.

Seafood and richer starters add range. Individual diners highlight chicken-fried lobster, prawns and octopus, while short rib and mac and cheese reinforce the restaurant’s indulgent steakhouse style. These dishes do not recur often enough in the supplied sample to establish the same consensus as the filet, but the reports are favorable.

Dessert feedback is more mixed. One diner was highly enthusiastic about the peanut butter dessert. Another found the gluten-free dessert selection limited to ice cream and sorbet, despite reporting many gluten-free choices elsewhere in the meal.

Service and atmosphere

Hospitality is one of the strongest themes across the reviews. Diners repeatedly describe the staff as attentive, welcoming, conversational and professional. Recommendations and attention to detail receive specific praise, suggesting that the service team plays a substantial role in shaping the experience.

The room is described as elevated and fantastic, aligning with the restaurant’s fine-dining positioning. One review also calls out an impressive wine selection and the discovery of a Greek winery. That is only a single account, but it indicates potential appeal for guests who value a broader bottle list alongside steak.

The editorial read

Synthesizing the rating and review patterns, Prime + Proper looks best suited to diners who want a high-end Nashville steakhouse with strong service at the center of the experience. The filet is the safest evidence-backed order, and the broader steak selection appears to be the restaurant’s main strength.

Gluten-free diners seem to have substantial savory flexibility, though anyone expecting a composed gluten-free dessert may want to confirm current options. Cost is the other clear consideration. This is an expensive occasion restaurant, but the supplied reviews largely indicate that the cooking, atmosphere and hospitality justify the premium positioning.