Pies & Pints pairs creative pizza with a busy pub setting

What the public feedback suggests

Pies & Pints holds a 4.7 Google rating from 4264 reviews, and the sample feedback points to pizza as the main reason for its popularity. Diners describe the pies in emphatic terms, with praise spanning familiar combinations and more distinctive choices. Mentioned orders include Italian pizza, Grape and Gorgonzola, Mushroom/Garlic, Cheese, and Pine and Swine.

This is not presented as a quiet neighborhood pizzeria. The available accounts describe a popular, mid range restaurant with pub and bar elements, plenty of indoor seating and an outdoor seating area. It appears well suited to a meal after exploring the Fayetteville area, including a Bridge Walk outing mentioned by one visitor.

Food and drink

Pizza earns the most consistent approval. One reviewer called both the Italian and Grape and Gorgonzola pizzas very good, while another considered the pizza among the best they had eaten. A half Mushroom/Garlic and half Cheese pie was described as fresh and delicious. Pine and Swine, made with pineapple and bacon according to the review, also received a positive mention.

The supporting menu items fare well in this small review sample. Char-grilled wings drew especially strong praise, while garlic bread and nachos were also singled out as successful starters. Draft root beer appears in more than one account. One diner appreciated being offered samples of two varieties before choosing, while another simply described the on-draft root beer as great. Beer is part of the restaurant’s appeal as well, although the supplied feedback does not identify specific pours.

Atmosphere and service

Reviews depict an attractive, comfortable space rather than a cramped pizza parlor. Indoor tables, bar high-tops and outdoor seating give parties several possible ways to settle in. One customer facing a 40-minute table wait was seated immediately at a bar high-top instead. Another noted a large and comfortable outdoor waiting area during a much longer delay.

Service reports are mixed but lean positive. Several diners describe servers or bartenders as polite, helpful, warm or attentive. One account, however, says the waitress disappeared after taking the order, leaving the diner to request the check from another employee. The food was still rated highly in that review, but the experience suggests service can become uneven when the restaurant is busy.

Before going

Demand is the main concern. Reported waits range from 40 minutes to 1.5 hours for a table, so peak periods may require patience. Bar seating can provide a useful alternative for smaller parties when available.

Pet owners should also take note: one reviewer reports that dogs were not permitted in the outdoor seating area. Because policies can change, checking directly with the restaurant remains sensible. Overall, the public evidence supports Pies & Pints as a strong Fayetteville choice for creative pizza, wings and draft drinks, provided diners account for crowds and occasional service lapses.