Bison burgers and beer lead the draw in Thermopolis

What the ratings suggest

One Eyed Buffalo Brewing Company carries a 4.5 Google rating from more than 2,000 reviews, a substantial base that signals broad approval rather than a brief run of enthusiasm. Public listings place it in the moderate price tier and classify it as a brewpub, pub, bar and restaurant. In practice, the review sample points to a straightforward appeal: burgers, beer and an informal atmosphere suited to travelers and locals looking for a casual meal.

The positive reports are often emphatic. Some diners describe it as one of their best meals while passing through Thermopolis, and another says it was the place locals recommended for burgers. Others are more measured, finding the food decent but not compelling enough for a return visit. That split makes the 4.5 rating useful context: satisfaction appears high overall, but individual experiences vary.

The case for the bison burger

The bison burger, also called a buffalo burger in the reviews, is the clearest recurring order. Diners repeatedly note well-cooked patties, with medium and medium-rare preparations specifically mentioned. The strongest accounts describe the meat as juicy and flavorful, supported by a bun and fresh vegetables. Even less enthusiastic reviewers generally place the burger around average or slightly above average rather than calling it a failure.

Sides are less consistent. Seasonal vegetables earn praise in two accounts, including a serving of seasoned broccoli and cauliflower. Fries are described as hot and fresh in one review. Brussels sprouts, however, were reported as severely undercooked, while salads received an average assessment. An optional grilled-onion add-on was also considered poor value by one diner.

Beer and atmosphere

Beer is the other dependable reason to stop. Reviewers call the beers good or alright, with one particularly positive mention for a hazy beer and another for large pours. The feedback does not establish a single must-order beer, but it does support One Eyed Buffalo as a practical burger-and-beer destination.

Atmosphere receives favorable, if varied, descriptions ranging from decent to energetic and distinctive. That makes the restaurant a plausible fit for a relaxed pub meal rather than a quiet or polished dining occasion. Friendly staff are also mentioned, including within reviews that criticize the pace of service.

Service can shape the visit

Service is the main caution in the supplied feedback. One party experienced long waits to be acknowledged, receive a queue number, get a table and finally receive food. Another called the service average, while a more positive account reported no wait and fast service. The pattern suggests timing and crowd levels may have a meaningful effect on the experience.

Taken together, public ratings and reviews make One Eyed Buffalo a solid Thermopolis choice for a bison burger with beer. The food is not uniformly praised, and some sides appear less reliable than the main attraction, but the signature burger, friendly pub atmosphere and strong overall rating give it a credible case for a first visit.