Old Stove Brewing Co pairs waterfront views with pub fare

The public-review read

Old Stove Brewing Co’s Pike Place location earns much of its appeal from the setting. Across the supplied public feedback, diners repeatedly focus on the upper-waterfront outlook, especially around sunset or during clear weather. The room and patio appear well suited to visitors who want Seattle scenery alongside a casual meal, though that same draw can make the restaurant busy by late afternoon.

The broader rating supports that positive picture: Google lists Old Stove at 4.5 from 5697 reviews. In the review sample, the strongest praise goes to the views, beer selection and generally welcoming atmosphere. Service receives several favorable mentions as well, including descriptions of attentive and warm staff. One diner, however, reports slower service and delays in seating open tables, possibly during an understaffed period.

Food and drink strengths

Fish and chips provide the clearest food recommendation. Multiple diners ordered the dish, with praise for crisp fish and an overall satisfying pub-style plate. Consistency may vary, since one order arrived with cold chips even though the fish itself was considered good.

Other positive mentions cover the burger and fries, pretzel bites with beer cheese, sandwiches and a notably well-received hummus plate. The hummus was served with pita described as crisp outside and soft inside. Beer cheese also made a strong impression as both an accompaniment for pretzel bites and a dip for fries.

As expected from a brewpub, beer is central to the experience. Reviews mention a wide variety of house microbrews, the ability to assemble a custom flight and opportunities to sample before committing. Wine and cocktails broaden the options for groups with mixed drinking preferences. Based on the supplied price level, the restaurant falls into the mid-range category.

Where the experience can slip

The pizza draws the sharpest criticism in this review set. One diner found the flatbread-style portions disappointing, with one crust overdone and another soggy. That report stands apart from the more favorable comments about sandwiches, burgers and fried pub staples, suggesting pizza may be a less reliable order.

Crowds are another practical concern. A late-afternoon arrival reportedly led to a wait, and outdoor patio tables were especially difficult to secure. Since the view is a major reason diners choose this location, competition for scenic seating appears predictable. Service speed can also falter when the restaurant is packed.

Verdict

Synthesizing the rating and supplied reviews, Old Stove looks strongest as a scenic brewpub rather than a destination for ambitious cooking. The winning plan centers on a beer flight, fish and chips or another straightforward pub order, plus time to enjoy the waterfront setting. The combination of views, drinks and an energetic atmosphere makes it particularly attractive for visitors exploring Pike Place or meeting friends around sunset. Diners focused primarily on pizza, quick seating or guaranteed patio access may find the experience less dependable.