Martone’s Market & Café Goes Big on Fresh Sandwiches

What the public feedback says

Martone’s Market & Café carries a 4.7 Google rating from 609 reviews, a notably strong showing for an everyday sandwich shop. The available feedback repeatedly centers on three qualities: generous portions, fresh ingredients and friendly service. Several diners call the sandwiches massive or enormous, while also stressing that they are made fresh to order rather than assembled in advance.

That consistency helps explain why Martone’s is described as a staple and a repeat stop for visitors to Vermont. Reviews do not frame it as a formal dining destination. Instead, it reads as a reliable, budget-friendly café where the food is substantial and the staff keeps the experience welcoming.

Sandwiches lead the menu

The Italian sub is the clearest recurring recommendation in the sampled reviews. Diners describe it as piled high, made with locally baked fresh bread and filled generously rather than bulked out with fillers. One reviewer specifically ordered it without mayonnaise, suggesting that customization is readily accommodated.

The Vermont sandwich also receives a detailed mention. That combination features turkey, maple ham, lettuce, tomato and cheddar on whole wheat. It appears only once in the supplied feedback, so it is better treated as an example of Martone’s broad sandwich range than as a consensus favorite.

Customization is a larger pattern. Reviewers say customers can build their own sandwiches, choose from the café’s established options or request familiar classics. Bread, meats and other ingredients are regularly characterized as fresh and high quality. The result is a shop suited both to diners who already know their order and those looking for one of the menu’s named combinations.

Service and setting

Large sandwiches are not the only reason Martone’s stands out in public feedback. Staff members are repeatedly described as friendly, fast and accommodating. One diner noticed multiple catering orders being prepared but still reported prompt attention and efficient ordering. That is useful evidence for anyone concerned that a popular counter-service stop might become bogged down when larger orders are underway.

The indoor seating area also earns praise for feeling cozy and having an appealing atmosphere. Another review notes that the morning coffee menu looked promising, though the supplied comments do not offer enough detail to evaluate specific drinks. Martone’s therefore comes across primarily as a sandwich destination with café appeal, rather than a coffee shop whose beverage program has been fully documented by these reviews.

The editorial take

Based on the rating, review volume and repeated themes, Martone’s is an easy Essex Junction recommendation for a filling casual meal. The Italian sub has the strongest support, while the build-your-own flexibility should work well for diners with specific preferences. Portions appear exceptionally large, so lighter eaters may want to plan accordingly. For diners seeking fresh bread, abundant fillings, quick service and a comfortable place to slow down, the public record is unusually consistent.