Market House Meats Builds Its Reputation on Hefty Sandwiches

What the public feedback says

Market House Meats carries a 4.8 Google rating from 830 reviews, a strong signal for a deli and sandwich shop with a straightforward specialty. Across the sample feedback, diners repeatedly focus on three things: generously filled meat sandwiches, friendly service and solid value for the portion size.

The praise is often emphatic. Several diners call the sandwiches among their Seattle favorites, while others describe return visits driven by consistent food and welcoming staff. Service appears to be more than a footnote here. Reviews mention quick preparation, smiles and easy conversation at the counter, suggesting a personable operation rather than a purely transactional lunch stop.

Pastrami and Reuben lead the order

Pastrami is the clearest recurring recommendation. Reviewers describe substantial servings and pair it favorably with the corned beef sandwich. The Reuben also earns repeated endorsements, including from returning diners. These are the orders that best represent the public consensus around Market House Meats: filling, meat-forward deli sandwiches served without much fuss.

Potato salad appears often enough to deserve attention as a side. One diner called it very good, while another reported receiving it alongside pickles and small cookies with a sandwich. Those extras may help explain why several reviews frame the portions as a good deal. One particularly enthusiastic customer described a whole sandwich as effectively enough food for two sandwiches.

Other items receive praise, including a Philly cheesesteak and a cheeseburger combo, but they appear less frequently in the supplied feedback. First-time visitors looking to follow the strongest review patterns should start with pastrami or a Reuben.

A note on expectations

Not every pastrami experience is flawless. One dissenting reviewer found the sandwich too dry and pushed back on comparisons with Katz’s. That criticism matters because the otherwise enthusiastic feedback could create outsized expectations, especially for diners accustomed to famous East Coast delicatessens.

Still, even that skeptical review considered Market House Meats a solid local option. The broader pattern remains highly positive, with multiple diners praising both the pastrami and the overall experience. The useful takeaway is not that every sandwich will satisfy every deli purist, but that this shop has built unusual consistency across a large body of public feedback.

Value and overall verdict

The listed price level is moderate, placing Market House Meats in the mid-range category. Reviews nevertheless describe the sandwiches as reasonably priced or a good value, largely because of their size and the reported accompaniments. Diners with smaller appetites may find a whole sandwich more than necessary for one sitting.

Based on the available ratings and review patterns, Market House Meats is best suited to anyone prioritizing abundant portions, classic deli meats and notably kind counter service. The pastrami has one documented dryness complaint, but repeated praise for the pastrami, Reuben, potato salad and staff makes this a high-confidence Seattle sandwich recommendation.