Latchkey Deli Builds Its Case on Reubens and Italians

The public verdict

Latchkey Deli carries a 4.7 Google rating from 374 reviews, a strong showing for a budget-friendly sandwich shop. Across the public feedback sampled, the recurring themes are consistency, generous portions and fair value. One longtime customer reports returning for two years without seeing the quality slip, while another describes a half sandwich and potato salad as filling enough for a meal on the go.

That makes Latchkey look especially useful for travelers, quick lunches and anyone who wants deli comfort food without stretching into an expensive meal. Its listing also identifies it as a catering and delivery business, though the reviews provided focus more on the food itself than those services.

Start with the Reuben or Italian

The Reuben earns the most emphatic praise. Reviewers highlight its combination of pastrami and corned beef, with one initially skeptical diner finding the pairing delicious and worth ordering again. Another review calls it a “Fire Reuben,” especially notable because the same diner was much less impressed by the BLT. There is one caution: the Reuben was described as a little salty, so salt-sensitive diners may want to keep that in mind.

The Italian is the other repeat recommendation. Public comments describe it as generously filled with meat rather than skimpy, and it appears to hold up as a reliable regular order. Taken together, the Reuben and Italian form the clearest starting point for a first visit.

Vegetarian diners are not treated as an afterthought, at least based on the feedback available. The veggie sandwich uses smoked beet, and one reviewer praised the preparation even though the diner who ordered it does not usually like beets. That is a specific but encouraging signal for anyone seeking something beyond a basic pile of raw vegetables.

Sides are part of the appeal

Mac and cheese comes up repeatedly and with unusually strong approval. One regular pairs it with the Italian and calls it some of the best they have had, while another review recommends it alongside the deli’s scalloped potatoes and homemade potato chips. The potato salad also receives a positive mention with a gluten-free half sandwich.

These comments suggest the sides are worth treating as more than automatic add-ons. Mac and cheese is the safest consensus pick, while potato salad, scalloped potatoes and homemade chips provide alternatives depending on availability and preference.

What to order carefully

The BLT is the clearest weak point in this review set. One detailed critique says it leaned too heavily on bacon that was not crisp enough, while the tomato lacked the prominence and seasoning expected from a standout BLT. That is only one account, but it is specific enough to weigh against the broader praise elsewhere.

Gluten-free diners have at least one encouraging report involving a half sandwich, though the limited feedback does not establish the full range of gluten-free choices or preparation practices. Overall, public sentiment makes Latchkey Deli an easy Lawrence recommendation for hearty sandwiches, strong comfort-food sides and budget-friendly portions, with the Reuben, Italian and mac and cheese offering the most consistent evidence.