Lake Wales Cheese Shoppe & Deli Delivers on Sandwiches

What public feedback suggests

Lake Wales Cheese Shoppe & Deli carries a 4.8 Google rating from 288 reviews, and the supplied comments paint a consistent picture of a dependable local lunch stop. Diners repeatedly praise fresh sandwiches, welcoming employees and counter staff willing to explain the menu or make recommendations. The enthusiasm is broad rather than tied to a single item, with positive mentions spanning hot pressed sandwiches, deli classics, chicken salad and barbecue.

The setting also receives a few small but telling compliments. One reviewer noticed fresh flowers on the tables, while another appreciated a slice of watermelon served with the sandwiches. Those details support the overall impression of a casual shop that pays attention to presentation without turning lunch into a formal affair.

Sandwiches lead the menu

The Italian Cheese Melt Panini is described in one review as a signature favorite, with freshness and flavor singled out. Another diner was especially impressed by the cheese pull, suggesting that melted-cheese sandwiches are a clear strength. That same feedback credits what the diner described as fresh Amish ingredients, though the provided material does not offer further sourcing details.

The Rachel pastrami Reuben earns more specific praise for its ratio of meat, cheese, sauerkraut and marbled rye. Balance matters in a sandwich this rich, and the review indicates that no single component overwhelmed the others. A Cajun turkey sandwich paired with habanero-jalapeño cheese brings a spicier option, while the Cuban and pulled pork broaden the selection beyond traditional cold deli combinations.

Chicken salad also appears to be made in house, according to one diner, and was praised for its taste. Potato salad received a positive mention alongside the pulled pork. Taken together, the reviews suggest a menu with enough range for groups who may want different styles of lunch while still keeping sandwiches at the center.

Service appears to be a major strength

Warm service is one of the clearest patterns in the public comments. Reviewers describe employees as friendly, welcoming and helpful, including a counter worker who walked first-time diners through the menu and offered recommendations. Another customer said the staff created a home-like feeling on repeat visits.

That consistency is important for a deli, where a quick counter interaction can shape the whole experience. The available feedback suggests the team handles both hospitality and menu guidance well. Lake Wales Cheese Shoppe & Deli also lists catering and delivery among its services, although the supplied reviews focus on meals eaten at or picked up from the shop rather than those offerings.

Editorial take

Based on the rating and review patterns, this is a strong candidate for a casual Lake Wales lunch built around a hot sandwich. The Italian Cheese Melt Panini and Rachel pastrami Reuben stand out for first-time orders, while the Cajun turkey with habanero-jalapeño cheese suits diners looking for more heat. Freshness and thoughtful sandwich construction drive the praise, but the consistently kind service may be the shop’s most reliable advantage.