Katzinger's Delicatessen delivers substantial sandwiches

What public feedback says

Katzinger's Delicatessen holds a 4.5 Google rating from 2625 reviews, and the available feedback points to a dependable Columbus stop for substantial sandwiches and classic deli sides. Diners repeatedly praise the freshness, generous portions and friendly staff. The casual setting also makes it suitable for a straightforward lunch while walking around German Village.

The line can look daunting during busy periods, but reviewers generally describe the operation as organized. One lunch-rush visitor was impressed by how smoothly the restaurant handled the crowd, while another found the moderate wait useful for studying the extensive menu. Staff members bring completed orders to the table, including outdoor seating, according to public feedback.

Sandwiches lead the menu

The sandwiches receive the clearest enthusiasm. A Reuben was described as fresh, flavorful and generously assembled, with properly grilled bread. The numbered sandwiches also attract attention. One diner praised the Number 69, a marinated and grilled take on a club sandwich, for the combination of bread, meat and sauces. Another enjoyed the Number 70 alongside chopped liver.

Portion size deserves attention before ordering. One review calls the deli-size sandwiches huge and recommends choosing a smaller version when a full portion sounds excessive. That makes Katzinger's appear budget friendly for diners who prioritize a filling meal, though the broad menu may require a few minutes of consideration at the counter.

Complimentary self-serve pickles are another recurring positive. Reviewers mention them as both a pleasant bonus and part of the traditional deli experience. They are not the main reason to visit, but they reinforce the restaurant's casual, generous character.

Sides, sweets and dietary needs

Beyond sandwiches, the sampled reviews offer favorable reports on hot kugel, potato knish, chopped liver and cheesecake. The kugel was specifically appreciated for being served hot. A first-time knish diner also responded positively to the potato version. These comments suggest that the supporting deli staples are worth considering rather than automatically settling for a sandwich alone.

One reviewer with celiac disease reported that the kitchen prepared a sandwich on gluten-free bread without cross-contamination and that the result exceeded expectations. That is encouraging, but it remains one diner's account rather than a guarantee. Guests with celiac disease or serious allergies should confirm current preparation procedures directly with the restaurant before ordering.

Editorial verdict

Synthesizing the rating and review patterns, Katzinger's looks strongest as a casual lunch destination for diners seeking an oversized deli sandwich, traditional sides and efficient service. The menu's range and numbered sandwiches may slow the initial decision, while the lunch rush can bring a line. Still, reviewers tend to view the wait as manageable and the staff as consistently welcoming.

The Reuben, numbered sandwiches and complimentary pickles form the clearest case for a visit. Smaller appetites should pay close attention to sandwich sizing, while anyone curious about classic deli accompaniments has several well-received options to add.