Gun Barrel Steak and Game House leans into bison and elk

The public verdict

Gun Barrel Steak and Game House holds a 4.4 Google rating from more than 2,800 reviews, a substantial sample that points to broad satisfaction. Public feedback most often praises the game meats, steaks, Western atmosphere and attentive service. The restaurant is listed as an expensive steakhouse and fine-dining restaurant, though its family-restaurant designation suggests a wider audience than the formal label might imply.

The strongest endorsements come from diners who treat the meal as a vacation highlight. One party returned the following night after an especially successful first dinner. Another described the experience as the best meal they had eaten, singling out the bison prime rib and elk. Those reactions make the restaurant particularly relevant for Jackson visitors who want a distinctly regional meat selection rather than a conventional steakhouse order.

What earns the praise

Bison is the clearest recurring favorite. A 7-ounce bison order was reportedly cooked to perfection and compelling enough for the same diner to order it again on a second visit. Another review praised the bison prime rib, while a separate guest trying a filet flight preferred the bison among the meats. Even a diner who ordered steak also sampled bison and highlighted its unusual flavor.

Steak receives plenty of support, too. Reviews mention a steak trimmings burger, marinated steak skewer, filet flight and more traditional steak orders. The steak trimmings burger was described with particular enthusiasm, and the marinated skewer was chosen by a returning guest. Side dishes mentioned favorably include truffle mac and mushrooms, while deep-dish apple pie drew an emphatic recommendation for dessert.

Service is another repeated strength. Diners describe staff as polite, efficient, sweet and attentive. One server received unusually strong praise for matching the quality of the food, while another review noted that water glasses were kept filled. Those details support the impression of a busy destination restaurant that can still deliver engaged table service.

Atmosphere and value

The Western character is part of the appeal rather than a minor decorative note. Multiple reviews explicitly appreciated the setting, especially in connection with trying bison or elk. That makes Gun Barrel a natural fit for visitors seeking a Jackson dinner that feels tied to the destination.

The main caution is cost. Public listings place it in the expensive tier, and one reviewer specifically warned that the restaurant is pretty pricey, even while concluding that the quality justified the expense. This is better framed as a planned dinner than an everyday meal.

Where expectations may split

Not every returning diner sees the current experience as equal to the restaurant’s earlier standard. A tour guide who had recommended Gun Barrel for years reported disappointment after returning following a four-year absence, saying the steak was not terrible but did not compare with previous visits. That is one dissenting account within an otherwise strong rating profile, but it matters at this price level.

Taken together, the reviews favor Gun Barrel for bison, game meats, Western atmosphere and attentive service. The 4.4 rating supports a positive recommendation, with the reservation that expensive steaks invite high expectations and occasional concerns about consistency.