Don & Charly’s Makes a Strong Case for Sandwich Lunch

What the ratings say

Don & Charly’s carries a 4.9 Google rating from 364 reviews, an unusually strong public score backed by recurring praise for generous sandwiches, fresh ingredients and friendly service. Reviewers commonly frame it as a downtown Boise lunch stop, with several describing substantial portions and sandwiches stacked with meat and other fillings.

The available reviews also suggest that speed is part of the appeal. One customer reported ordering and picking up within 10 minutes, while another specifically praised the fast service. That makes the shop look well suited to a quick lunch or takeout order, though the public feedback also mentions a pleasant atmosphere for those eating on-site. Its listed price level is moderate.

The sandwiches earning attention

The Italian Deli is the clearest repeat recommendation. One reviewer called out its balance of flavors and ingredients, while another praised its fresh meats, abundant filling and overall flavor. The Turkey Bacon received similarly positive feedback for its size and quality, and a bacon turkey club was described as so large that it was difficult to get around. Across those comments, portion size is not an afterthought. These appear to be hefty, filling sandwiches rather than restrained deli snacks.

The Caribbean Pork produced the most enthusiastic single response in the sample. Even a diner who generally does not choose sandwiches found it memorable enough to order again. That review also described it as very wet, which may be a positive for anyone who likes a saucy sandwich but less convenient for a tidy desk lunch.

Bread is another consistent strength. One review praised its soft interior and good crust, while even the least enthusiastic sandwich review said the bread was the best part. That kind of agreement matters at a sandwich shop, where mediocre bread can undermine otherwise good ingredients.

Sides, drinks and the weaker note

The potato salad stands out beyond the main menu. One diner considered it possibly the best they had eaten, making it a sensible pairing with the Italian Deli. A side salad also earned praise for fresh ingredients and good dressing.

Not every sandwich landed equally well. The chicken bahn mi was described as bland, although its bread still impressed and the diner remained willing to return for another menu choice. That isolated criticism does not outweigh the broader pattern, but it does suggest that the Italian Deli, Turkey Bacon and Caribbean Pork have stronger support in this review sample.

Tractor soda was another specific plus for one reviewer. It is a small detail, but one that may help distinguish the lunch experience for diners who seek it out.

Editorial verdict

Based on its exceptionally high Google rating and the themes repeated in public reviews, Don & Charly’s looks like one of Boise’s stronger bets for a large, flavor-forward sandwich served without a long wait. The Italian Deli has the best direct consensus, while the Caribbean Pork appears suited to diners who want something richer and saucier. Strong bread, generous portions and upbeat service feedback round out the case. The main caution is practical: some sandwiches may be oversized or messy, and the chicken bahn mi drew a muted assessment from one diner.