Cribb's Sandwich & Sweet Shop Delivers on Size and Service

What the reviews suggest

Cribb's Sandwich & Sweet Shop earns a 4.8 Google rating from 374 reviews, and the available comments point to a small restaurant that gets the fundamentals right. Diners repeatedly emphasize friendly treatment, substantial sandwiches and a relaxed atmosphere. The praise is not limited to one signature order. Reviewers report good experiences with hot, cold and breakfast-style sandwiches, suggesting a menu with enough range for repeat lunch visits.

The shop also comes across as genuine rather than polished or formal. One reviewer described the setting as storybook-like and adorable, while others focused on personable interactions with the owner and staff. Taken together, the public feedback presents Cribb's as a budget-friendly neighborhood sandwich stop where hospitality matters as much as portion size.

Sandwiches and sweets

The BLT and French dip receive direct praise for being huge, making them logical choices for diners arriving hungry. A turkey bacon sandwich also impressed a reviewer who expected something basic but found the turkey especially tender and the serving generous in protein. Other favorable orders include the three meat, egg salad and chicken salad.

Breakfast has some flexibility here, too. One diner reported ordering a breakfast sandwich in the middle of the afternoon, a useful detail for anyone who prefers eggs later in the day. That does not establish that every breakfast item is always available, but it does suggest the kitchen may be more accommodating than a rigid morning-only counter.

The sweet-shop side gets less detail in the sample feedback, though cookies are specifically described as outstanding. They appear to be the clearest add-on for a sandwich order based on the comments provided.

Service and setting

Service is the strongest recurring theme. Reviewers describe the staff as fast, friendly, experienced and unusually considerate. One family noted that the team cut a toddler's food into small pieces, while another diner appreciated the owner's straightforward response when something went wrong. Those details suggest an operation that handles customers as individuals rather than simply moving orders across a counter.

Pet-friendly outdoor seating broadens the appeal for casual lunches with a dog. The atmosphere also seems suited to families, especially given the toddler accommodation mentioned in the feedback. Nothing in the sample reviews indicates a formal dining experience, so expectations should lean toward a personable sandwich shop rather than a full-service occasion restaurant.

The bottom line

Cribb's looks best for a filling, low-key meal supported by notably warm service. Portion-conscious diners may want to consider the reported sandwich size before adding several sides or sweets, but that is more a planning note than a criticism. With praise spread across the BLT, French dip, turkey bacon, three meat, egg salad, chicken salad and breakfast sandwich, the shop appears to offer dependable variety rather than relying on a single standout item.

For Lexington diners choosing between quick lunch options, the combination of large servings, flexible ordering, family-friendly attention and cookies gives Cribb's a clear identity. The public review pattern supports it as a strong budget-friendly choice for sandwiches and casual hospitality.