Cecil's remains a reliable Saint Paul deli favorite

What the public feedback says

Cecil's earns a 4.7 Google rating from 3048 reviews, and the supplied feedback presents it as a low-key Saint Paul institution rather than a polished destination restaurant. Several diners describe it as a local favorite or regular go-to, including one customer who reports visiting for more than 40 years. Reliability is the clearest theme: solid deli food, patient service, fair pricing and a broad sandwich selection keep people returning.

The atmosphere also receives consistent approval. One review calls the overall experience elite, citing the combination of food, service and character, while another notes the awards displayed on the walls. Prompt seating appears in the feedback, though the restaurant’s popularity and compact deli format may still shape the experience at busier times.

Sandwiches lead the menu

Beef sandwiches generate the strongest enthusiasm. The classic Reuben is praised for flavorful corned beef and bread described as baked fresh each day. The Russian Reuben also receives multiple recommendations, although one diner preferred the classic version. Pastrami gets a favorable mention, as do the barbecue beef sandwich and BLT. The barbecue beef is singled out for tender meat and a savory sauce.

Portion impressions are mostly positive, but not unanimous. One reviewer wished the Reuben had more meat, so diners expecting an especially overstuffed deli sandwich may want to temper expectations. Another customer felt the server pushed the pastrami after a burger had initially been requested. Neither comment overwhelms the broader pattern of satisfaction, but both are useful context.

Sides, soup and sweets

Cecil's functions as more than a sandwich counter. Reviews mention breakfast, matzo soup, a small bakery and a grocery area stocked with deli staples. Matzo soup receives direct praise, while chocolate hamantashen and strudel stand out among the bakery recommendations.

The included sides appear dependable rather than elaborate. Pasta salad is mentioned more than once, and potato salad and creamy coleslaw also draw approval. Fries are described favorably, with one diner comparing their style to Culver’s fries. Fruit is available as a side and was considered good by the reviewer who ordered it.

The editorial read

Based on the public rating and recurring review themes, Cecil's is best approached as a trusted neighborhood deli with a broad supporting cast. Reubens are the safest starting point, especially for a first visit, while matzo soup, coleslaw and a bakery item can round out the order. The bakery and grocery component also makes it practical for customers who want deli staples or something sweet to take away.

Pricing falls in the mid-range category, and reviewers generally consider it fair for the quality. Cecil's looks particularly well suited to a casual breakfast or lunch, a straightforward beef sandwich, or a multigenerational meal where familiar deli choices matter more than trend-driven presentation.