BRICK & BUTTER Builds Its Case on Hearty Sandwiches

The public verdict

BRICK & BUTTER holds a 4.7 Google rating from 332 reviews, a strong showing for an Orlando sandwich shop. Public feedback centers on substantial, made-to-order sandwiches, crisp fries and a casual ordering process. One visitor sampling several food trucks in the area felt this one stood above the rest, while another described it as a cool place to hang out with plenty of options.

The overall picture is favorable: sandwiches are the main attraction, portions can be generous, and food often arrives hot and fresh. There are consistency concerns, however, particularly around salt levels and how evenly some orders are assembled.

What earns the praise

The chicken parmesan sandwich receives specific approval for arriving hot, fresh and large, with curly fries on the side. Another delivery order that included the chicken parm, OG cheesesteak, Reuben and Butcher’s Cut found the sandwiches delicious across the board. That breadth matters because it suggests the appeal is not tied to a single menu item.

Fries are another recurring strength. Regular fries and sweet fries were described as especially crispy, well seasoned and moist inside. Curly fries also appear repeatedly alongside sandwich orders, making them the most obvious side to consider.

Ordering appears streamlined. One reviewer found the kiosk quick and easy to use, with only brief staff interaction. BRICK & BUTTER therefore looks particularly suited to diners who want a focused sandwich-and-fries meal without a formal service setup.

Where experiences vary

The sharpest criticism concerns the OG cheesesteak. One diner found it overwhelmingly salty and said the sandwich appeared to have no cheese. That review also pointed to similar salt complaints elsewhere, making seasoning the clearest risk in the available feedback. Portion distribution may vary as well, based on a complaint about receiving very few fries compared with another order.

The chicken parmesan sandwich has its own structural issue. Although praised for temperature, freshness and size, one diner reported that the coating separated from the chicken while eating. The flavor may still land, but the sandwich can be messy or less cohesive than expected.

Wait times may run longer because items are prepared to order. Delivery also changes the value equation. The listing places BRICK & BUTTER in the budget-friendly category, but one family order through a delivery platform still felt expensive after multiple sandwiches, sides and added service costs.

Bottom line

BRICK & BUTTER looks strongest for diners prioritizing hearty sandwiches and crisp fries over polished service. The chicken parmesan sandwich and curly fries have the clearest recurring support, while the OG cheesesteak is more divisive because of salt and cheese concerns. Based on the high public rating and the specific praise for freshness, portions and fried sides, it remains a worthwhile Orlando option, especially for pickup or kiosk ordering. Diners sensitive to salt may want to approach the cheesesteak cautiously.