Asterisk Supper Club brings books, tea and comfort food

What the reviews indicate

Asterisk Supper Club holds a 4.6-star Google rating from 1,247 reviews, a substantial base of feedback that suggests its appeal extends beyond novelty. Public comments repeatedly describe a charming, book-filled dining room paired with consistent food and attentive bar service. Diners return for celebrations, bring friends and family, and praise the restaurant as an experience rather than just a convenient meal.

Its literary presentation gets much of the attention. Bookshelves shape the room, while menus presented inside children’s books add a playful flourish. The setting is described as small and quaint, with bar seats, outdoor seating and community tables. That mix can feel intimate, though it may also be less private or spacious than some parties prefer.

Food and drinks

Short rib is the clearest consensus order. Multiple reviewers recommend it, describing it as flavorful and expertly cooked. No other main appears with the same frequency in the supplied feedback, although individual diners also speak positively about pot pie and meatloaf. Tea sandwiches receive praise as well, including a ham and brie version, but those mentions are less consistent across the review sample.

Tea is central to Asterisk’s identity. Reviewers mention multiple tea accommodations, tea sandwiches and the pleasure of lingering over tea during a busy afternoon. The drink program appears broader than tea alone: comments note an extensive selection of drinks, cocktails that feel distinctive and an impressive wine selection. Desserts also earn enthusiasm, particularly from diners marking special occasions.

Atmosphere and occasions

The strongest pattern is celebratory use. Reviewers cite birthdays, Mother’s Day and other important gatherings, often emphasizing the attractive room and memorable presentation. The shelves, unusual menus and afternoon-tea elements create a setting that feels more theatrical than a standard neighborhood restaurant without displacing the food itself.

Service feedback in this sample is favorable. Bartenders are described as patient and friendly, while another reviewer singled out a staff interaction as part of a positive holiday visit. Even during a crowded Mother’s Day service, the ambience and tea helped make the wait feel manageable.

Before booking

The menu can change, and at least one diner found that the selections available in person did not exactly match the online menu. Guests focused on a particular dish should confirm current availability rather than treating an older menu as fixed.

Reservations also look prudent on weekends and major occasions. Reviews describe the restaurant as compact, and holiday demand can make it crowded. Pricing cannot be assessed confidently from the supplied listing data, so diners should consult the current menu when planning. Overall, the public record supports Asterisk as a strong choice for tea, celebrations and comfort-driven dinners in a highly distinctive room.