Andy's Deli Brings Old-School Sandwiches to Five Points

The read on Andy’s Deli

Andy’s Deli earns a 4.7 Google rating from 460 reviews, with public feedback centering on three consistent strengths: friendly service, filling sandwiches and an atmosphere rich in local character. This is not presented as a polished modern sandwich shop. Diners describe an old-fashioned Five Points institution where nostalgia is part of the appeal.

The walls receive nearly as much attention as the food. One reviewer likened the collection of Gamecock memorabilia to a museum and said staff traced pieces of it back to 1978. Others describe stepping inside as going back in time. That history appears to feel preserved rather than neglected, with feedback also noting that the restaurant is clean throughout.

What to order

Two sandwiches stand out in the supplied reviews. The Chicken Salad Sandwich was praised for creamy, well-seasoned chicken salad paired with crisp lettuce and juicy tomatoes. Its bread was described as soft but sturdy enough to hold the filling, while the portion was considered generous.

The Andy’s Special offers a heartier direction. A reviewer described it as loaded with roast beef and turkey, then topped with cheese and bacon. It arrived heated enough to melt the cheese. That combination, along with the deli’s broader menu variety, makes Andy’s a practical pick for diners seeking a substantial lunch rather than a small snack.

Comments about value are favorable, and the listing identifies Andy’s as inexpensive. In editorial terms, it fits the budget-friendly category. The available feedback supports ordering a signature sandwich or familiar deli staple rather than expecting an elaborate meal.

Service and atmosphere

Service is another repeated advantage. Reviewers call the staff friendly, efficient, courteous and helpful. One account describes a jam-packed lunch rush handled well despite the restaurant being short staffed. Another highlights personal kindness from the owner outside the restaurant. Together, those reports suggest a business that maintains an approachable, community-minded tone even when busy.

Seating appears flexible for a deli, with plenty of tables inside and some outdoor seating mentioned in feedback. The visual clutter of sports memorabilia is central to the experience, especially for Gamecock fans and diners drawn to longstanding local restaurants. Those seeking minimalist decor or a quiet, contemporary café may find the room less aligned with their preferences.

Editorial verdict

Based on the supplied rating, menu references and review patterns, Andy’s Deli looks best suited to a casual Columbia lunch. Its appeal rests on generous deli sandwiches, budget-friendly value and a setting packed with local nostalgia. The main caution is timing: lunch can become crowded, and staffing may feel stretched during peak periods. Even so, public feedback indicates that the team generally handles those rushes with patience and efficiency.