5th & Taylor Brings Upscale Group Dining to Germantown

The public verdict

5th & Taylor carries a Google rating of 4.6 from 1819 reviews, and the supplied feedback presents it as a reliable choice for an upscale dinner in Nashville’s Germantown neighborhood. Diners repeatedly praise the food, table service and atmosphere, with several describing an experience that worked especially well for families or other large parties.

The restaurant is expensive, so expectations should be set accordingly. Based on public reviews, much of its appeal comes from combining a special-occasion setting with shareable starters, substantial entrees and attentive service. It appears better suited to a planned evening out than a quick, casual meal.

Food that earns repeat praise

Appetizers receive some of the most enthusiastic comments. The hamachi crudo and cheddar biscuits are specifically recommended in one review, while duck wings and bacon-wrapped quail also went over well with a group. Another table praised the Florida rock shrimp and chicken liver and foie gras terrine. A large party reported trying several appetizers without finding a weak selection.

Steak is the clearest recurring entree strength. One diner said the steaks were cooked exactly as requested, while another singled out the Wagyu steak. Mashed potatoes also appear across multiple accounts, including as an accompaniment brought to the table. Mac and cheese generated a lively positive debate within one group, although it appears in only one of the supplied reviews.

Other named entrees include beer can chicken and a grilled wedge. Taken together, the comments suggest a broad American menu that rewards groups willing to order several starters and sides for the table.

Atmosphere and service

The interior makes a stronger impression than the exterior. One traveler described a dramatic shift from a plain facade to an exuberant, chic and cozy dining room, with industrial, greenhouse-like and museum-like elements. That mix sounds visually busy, but the same reviewer still found the space relaxing and comfortable.

Table service is another consistent advantage. Reviewers mention excellent attention, including from a server handling a large party. That matters at a restaurant where groups may be coordinating multiple appetizers, steaks and shared sides. The feedback indicates that the dining-room team generally keeps the experience polished even when the table is sizable.

What to consider before booking

The main caution concerns arrival rather than the meal itself. One diner reported a standoffish reception at the front desk and nearly left, though the rest of the staff and the overall dinner recovered the evening. It is a single complaint within otherwise warm service feedback, but it is worth noting.

Overall, 5th & Taylor looks best for celebratory dinners, visiting family and larger groups seeking an upscale Nashville setting. The strongest order, based strictly on recurring review patterns, centers on steak with mashed potatoes, supplemented by a selection of appetizers. Its expensive positioning and dramatic room make it less compelling for diners after simplicity, but public sentiment strongly favors the full experience.